Foster, J. (2003, July). Cooking as an Art Form Raven Chronicles. Retrieved October 18, 2007 from http://www.ravenchronicles.org/FoodCulture/cookingasanartform.html.
Though short in length, this article vividly describes the authors perspective on cooking as an art form. At the beginning of the essay Foster states the Encylopedia Britannica’s definition of “a work of art,” which includes the word “aesthetically” as we have seen in Tefler’s article. Foster continues on a short jaunt to show the reader how he thinks art has an impact, and the greater the aesthetic function, the greater the impact, therefore cooking is potentially the greatest art form. The rest of the article is devoted to providing the reader with a detailed description of Foster as a child, watching his dad cook bacon biscuits. He includes every detail of how, aesthetically, the process tantalized his every sense, until finally he was able to partake of the “work of art.”
In my view, the Foster does make a few points, but jumps a bit too quickly at the assumption that cooking may be one of the greatest forms of art. While cooking make an aesthetic impression on most all of our senses including sight, sound (bacon sizzling), smell, etc), these aesthetic impressions might not be the lasting, “re-vistable” kind that some might consider as art. In Tefler’s article, she explained that one of the arguments against food as an art form is that even though food is aesthetically stimulating, it usually is not for the same reasons that a painting or a sculpture is stimulating. A person cannot usually gaze upon the work of art, and usually does not dwell on the piece of art, contemplating its meaning, purpose, or focus. Foster almost reinforces this statement, though I doubt he meant to when he says that “[frying bacon] is more like a symphony than a poem, more like a sunset than a painting.” This is exactly what Tefler was refering too when she says that though some things are aesthetically stimulating, not all should be considered art.
Smillie, S. (2007, May). Is Food Art? Word of Mouth – The Observer: Food Monthly. Retrieved October 18, 2007 from http://blogs.guardian.co.uk/food/2007/05/theatre_of_food.html.
In this article, Smillie focuses on the ongoing debate between conventional artists and the contemporary artists of the food culture. She talks mainly about the uproar among experts, which arose after wonderchef, Ferran Adria was invited to display his food-art-work at a German art show. He was one of the only two spaniards, which fuled the fire further more, as the art community in Spain does not consider his work as an art form. Smillie provides an antoginistic view against food as art, but continues to ask, “Why not?” After arguing her point, which I will touch on later, she points out that as with all artistic movements people such as Adria continue to stretch the boundaries. She concludes with the argument from these wonderchefs that preparing and serving food is possibly the most complex of the performing arts because it engages the senses as well as the mind. This is a similar argument to that of Foster in the previous article.
Though some of Smillie’s arguments are similar to Fosters, I agree with Smillie much more, perhaps because of the way she presented her argument for food as art. Her argument seems to coincide more with that of Tefler’s argument in that even though some food is eaten to please the hunger, and chefs do cook for the people’s enjoyment, there are many chefs who could care less about their “eaters’” tates. They are more concerned with the critic’s eye, and let us search high and low for any artist that is not concerned with the critic’s eye. I enjoyed how Smillie points out that it is not for the expert to decide on what art is, but it is up to the viewer. Smillie applauds these chefs along with the administrators of these art shows that are willing to push these boundaries and include some of these new and exciting art forms that are “stirring” in the art world of today.
No comments:
Post a Comment